Showing posts with label inequality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label inequality. Show all posts

Friday, 30 April 2010

Unemployed young northerners

In last night’s leaders’ debate all three parties emphasised the importance of increasing the number of apprenticeships and vocational training to help build our industrial base and get young people back into work. This is to be welcomed.

ippr north is currently researching some of the most deprived communities in northern England. For many of the young people we have spoken to, one of the major barriers they face in getting into work is having to have previous experience. They agree that having more apprenticeships and in-work training opportunities would most help them get into work. It’s also their experience that education and qualifications do not help, but ‘who you know’ does – which is also difficult for them to achieve.

These young people are critical of training courses that do not lead to work. Too often the major objective is simply for young people to be ‘seen’ to be meaningfully occupied; if the process has no job prospect at the end, there is a danger of vulnerable young people becoming even more disillusioned about the benefits of education and the opportunities available to them. This risks lowering aspiration, and reinforcing a belief that education does not lead to employment.

But perhaps most fundamentally for the North, the majority of the election debate has been focused on the issues of ‘labour supply’ – particularly training and skills – perhaps because this is the area where the leaders feel they have most levers.

For a sustainable recovery to happen in the North, the parties must do more to tackle the thorny issue of creating new, high-quality, low-skilled jobs. Only when jobs offer the opportunity for progression and decent pay, can they truly offer a way for people to improve their lives. The risk otherwise is that we further entrench inequality.

Evelyn Tehrani

Thursday, 8 April 2010

Labour and income inequality

The gap between rich and poor in the UK has widened since 1997, according to the results of a recent study by the Institute for Fiscal Studies. It found that income inequality in 2007-08 was higher than when Labour came to power and ‘higher than in any year since at least the 1950s’.

On the face of it, this is unwelcome reading for Labour supporters. What is the point of 13 years of Labour Government if it cannot prevent widening income inequalities?

Dig deeper into the IFS’s analysis, however, and it becomes clear that the gap between rich and poor has widened despite the Government’s efforts, not because of them. In the 1980s, when government policies seemed designed to benefit the rich, income inequality increased by an enormous amount. The increase in income inequality under Labour has been far smaller because changes to the tax and benefit system since 1997 have favoured poorer households at the expense of richer ones.

But what is missing from this analysis is an understanding of the causes of the increases in inequality that have occurred before the effects of government policy are taken into account. Throughout the last three decades, it seems, underlying inequality has been increasing. In the 1980s, this was exacerbated by government policy; over the last 13 years it has been mitigated by it. But under Conservative and Labour governments alike, it has remained a powerful trend.

There are a host of explanations for this trend, including globalisation, technological change and the dominance of the financial sector in the UK economy and we need to develop a full understanding of them because – as Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett have demonstrated so conclusively in their book The Spirit Level – greater inequality leaves everyone worse off.

So, while it is right to challenge the main political parties during the election campaign on how their tax and benefit policies might affect income inequality, it is perhaps more important to ask them what they intend to do about the growing disparity in pre-tax incomes. If they are, to quote Lord Mandelson, ‘intensely relaxed about people getting filthy rich’, they shouldn’t be.

Tony Dolphin

Thursday, 11 March 2010

How fair is Brown’s recovery?


In his speech on the economy yesterday the Prime Minister underlined the need for a fair economy, with growth that will ‘preserve and expand the jobs – and lift the standards of life – of the British people.’

But a fair economy is not simply about restoring growth. Brown’s progressive goals are dependent on how the rewards of growth are distributed. Several high profile reports have recently revealed that strong growth in the decade before the financial crisis failed to address the acute inequality – geographic, social and economic – embedded in British society.

So, after the bust, how will Brown’s recovery fare on fairness?

Efforts to tackle inequality have typically focused on reducing poverty – a noble aim, but it offers limited mileage without parallel endeavours to redistribute the vast wealth at the top. Brown is therefore right to limit top earners with wage freezes for senior public sector workers – a measure first advocated by the Conservative Party.

But while the public sector may hope to set an example, Brown remains silent on wage inequality in the private sector – an indication, perhaps, of the persistent belief that high wages drive entrepreneurialism.

Over a fifth of UK workers are low paid – and millions more are stuck in poor quality, insecure jobs. The rewards of the boom years passed these workers by. The rise of the knowledge economy led to new highly skilled and highly paid jobs, while the low skilled sector consisted increasingly of poor quality jobs in the service economy. Social mobility has remained stagnant for decades, partly as a consequence of this polarisation between lovely and lousy jobs.

Yet the strategy announced yesterday does not rise to this challenge. It reiterates promises from January’s growth strategy to invest in high quality infrastructure and scientific innovation. These measures may well create jobs of the future, and high skill industries will surely secure UK growth and a strong position in global trade. But the Government has offered no policies to improve the quality of employment at the bottom or tackle the low pay that persists in many industries.

Tess Lanning, Researcher, ippr