Showing posts with label budget. Show all posts
Showing posts with label budget. Show all posts

Friday, 9 April 2010

Why limit top pay only in the public sector?

In an article in today's Guardian David Cameron proposes establishing a fair pay review into pay inequality in the public sector and asking it ‘to consider how to introduce a pay multiple so that no public sector worker can earn over 20 times more than the lowest paid person in their organisation’.

Putting aside the vagueness of the language – Prime Ministers have to make decisions, not pass them over to a review to consider and I’m left wondering what would happen if the review refused to contemplate the idea? – this is a proposal with some merit.

But why limit it to the public sector? David Cameron argues that a pay multiple would ‘help tackle unfair pay policies’ and ‘improve cohesion and morale’. Shouldn’t unfair pay policies be tackled in the private sector too? Wouldn’t improved cohesion and morale in the private sector help the economy recover more strongly from recession?

Whatever the result of the general election, the next government will expect senior public sector workers to behave more like their counterparts in the private sector. They will be expected to deliver the ‘efficiency savings’ that both the main parties hope will prove to be a painless way of reducing the budget deficit (they won’t, but that’s a different story). They will be charged with lifting productivity growth in the public sector into line with productivity growth in the private sector.

So why not treat senior workers in the public and private sectors the same. Forget the review. Just stop anyone in any organisation earning more than 20 times the pay of the lowest paid person in their organisation. According to David Cameron, ‘Some of our most successful private sector companies operate a pay multiple’. Let’s try it out on all of them.

Tony Dolphin

Friday, 26 March 2010

Why might we want a Child Poverty Act?

The Child Poverty Act, which commits future governments to meeting Labour’s goal of eradicating child poverty by 2020, received Royal Assent yesterday. But why might we want an Act of this kind?

The obvious answer is that ending child poverty is the right thing to do and making it law will ensure the goal is met. But the greatest progress on child poverty was made in the first part of the 2000s, before Labour had even thought about enacting a child poverty law. Tony Blair’s pledge to end child poverty was made in 1999, yet the idea of enshrining it in law wasn’t aired until Gordon Brown’s 2008 conference speech. So why do we need a law now?

Child poverty rates began to creep up after 2004, which reflected a slackening off in investment in anti-poverty measures. So perhaps Labour felt that it needed a law to make itself put its investment back on track. Let’s hope not – it would be a slightly odd way of going about things. And it hasn’t worked, as the meagre child poverty measures in Wednesday’s Budget showed.

A more plausible explanation is that this is a political move, because it forces the Conservatives to stick to Labour’s poverty goals. The Tories have come round to the idea of relative poverty but often argue that poverty is about much more than income. Should they form the next government, they may prefer not to have their hands tied by an Act that so explicitly prioritises income-based measures of poverty.

The other view is that the government wanted to look like it was doing something on child poverty at a time when the figures were, and still are, going in the wrong direction yet it was difficult, and still is, to find the cash to put things back on track. Drafting a bill and steering it through Parliament is a lot cheaper than putting an extra £4 billion into tax credits, which is what the Institute for Fiscal Studies said it would cost to half child poverty by this year.

It’s important not to get too cynical and forget the very impressive work that this government has done in tackling poverty, particularly among children and pensioners. But if you set yourself challenging and important targets, you have to do everything in your power to meet them. Now that we’ve got a Child Poverty Act, we should use it at every opportunity to hold the government, now and in the future, to account – but ending child poverty takes real action not just legislation.

Kayte Lawton, research fellow, ippr

An old age question


In his budget this week the Chancellor announced that us younger folk will have to wait a bit longer for our bus pass - he’s raising the entitlement age for concessionary travel to age 65 and hopes to save £60 million in the process. This makes a lot of sense – there isn’t any reason why benefits designed for older people should kick in before the age of retirement.

However the move raises a much thornier question. To what extent should benefits for older people be universal for all or targeted according to need?

A number of the benefits that older people receive – such as the winter fuel payment and free TV licence – are handed out on a universal basis. There are some big advantages to this: the take-up level is high so people don’t miss out; there is no stigma attached to getting support; the process is easy to administer; everyone has a stake in what is available; and it’s popular.

The trouble with universal benefits is that they are costly and do not distinguish between the different circumstances of the people who receive them. The bus pass may help someone who can’t drive or afford transport, but it also allows the well-off to travel from one end of the country to the other at no cost.

With spending cuts looming, the challenge for policy makers will be to find a better balance between universal and targeted support for older people. There are three options:

1. Introduce some form of means testing for these benefits. The trouble is that many people who would be eligible for the support would not claim it – we already see this problem with the Pension Credit Guarantee where take-up is about a third lower than it should be. That’s a lot of people missing out.
2. Keep the benefits as universal, but make them taxable. This would ensure that those who can afford to contribute towards the cost of their support do so, but they would do it through the tax system rather than up-front means testing.
3. Raise the age people are eligible to receive these benefits – perhaps to around 75. This is a very blunt way to save money, but we know that the risks of poverty, illness and low levels of well-being all increase rapidly after this age and that broadly speaking it’s that age group that need most support.

For what it's worth I think the second option is the best way to tread the line between ‘universal’ and ‘targeted’ support. But I wouldn’t expect any of these decisions to get much of an airing before the election – as yesterday’s budget demonstrated, tricky decisions about spending cuts will be saved for after May 6th.

Jonathan Clifton, researcher, ippr

Thursday, 25 March 2010

Cider house rules?

‘Leave cider alone’ groups on Facebook are proliferating as we speak. Who would have predicted that, faced with unprecedented levels of public debt and the need to drive down an enormous deficit, yesterday’s budget would be remembered as the day Alistair Darling cracked down on scrumpy.

The introduction of a10% above inflation rise in duty on cider is intended to address a ‘long-standing anomaly’ where cider drinkers have paid less duty per drink than beer drinkers. This is in line with budgets of the past few years which have tried to address another anomaly – up until the last few years, alcohol was around 70% more affordable as a proportion of income than it was in 1980.

But if this is also intended to address concerns about teenagers bingeing on Diamond White on park benches, it is unlikely to have a major impact. Underage drinking is most often done through older teens or adults buying cheap alcohol from supermarkets or discount stores, rather than pubs or clubs. The major supermarkets will simply absorb the increased duty rates and continue to use alcohol as a loss leader.

Political parties are caught between wanting to address the very real problem of vast increases in drinking among young people and adults over the past few decades and not wanting to penalise moderate drinkers. Only the SNP-led Scottish government is sticking its neck out by planning to introduce a minimum pricing policy which would see a floor price set for a unit of alcohol.

Some commentators have dismissed this approach as ‘regressive’, describing it as part of a ‘new temperance’ movement led by public health officials intent on restricting individual choice.

But we are living in a country which has seen a fivefold increase in liver disease over the last 30 years. Though fewer young people are drinking overall, those who do drink are drinking twice as much as their counterparts in the 1990s. Enforcement measures have, unsurprisingly, proven useless, resulting only in the criminalisation of more young people than virtually any other country in Europe.

According to research in the Lancet published yesterday, a 50p per unit minimum pricing policy would save around 2,900 lives a year and reduce costs to the health service by £270 million a year. So surely this is a policy at least worthy of serious consideration?

Clare McNeil, research fellow, ippr

Basic bank accounts to solve the personal finance crisis?


It’s safe to say that the Government’s Budget announcement that banks will be forced to provide basic bank accounts to everyone is a Good Thing. The Labour Government has already halved the number of people without a bank account, which, as Darling pointed out, is a useful tool for people’s personal finances. From buying a holiday to getting wages paid in, a bank account certainly comes in handy.

But is access to a bank account the critical personal finance issue of our times? Measures to increase financial education and improve access to financial products and services have been a major feature of efforts to tackle poverty and debt in recent years.

In fact, before the banking crash in 2007, the light touch regulation of banks was paralleled by increasing focus on the ability of individuals to manage their finances. Concern about the extraordinary rise in personal debt focused almost entirely on poor people: those with the smallest levels of debt but most associated with ‘problem debt’.

But, as ippr’s recent report Strength Against Shocks showed, people rarely get into financial difficulty because of ‘bad’ financial management. Poverty, sickness and unemployment are by far the biggest drivers of over-indebtedness.

The disparity between low pay structures and consumer-driven growth is an integral part of the story of debt in low income households. Successive governments have encouraged and supported our cultural obsessions with consumer comforts and home-ownership. But while Britain remains one of the most unequal countries in the developed world, many people on low incomes can only keep up with the Joneses – and the rising cost of living – by taking on debt.

Banks, as we know, have been only too happy to oblige, offering no-income-no-job-no-assets loans and mortgages. Low income families that took part in our research had been inundated with calls, letters and visits from loan companies urging them to manage their poverty through debt.

Financial products simply offer practical ways for poor people to manage limited resources, and access to basic bank accounts barely grazes the surface of Britain’s personal finance crisis. A radical pre-election pledge this is not.

Tess Lanning, researcher, ippr

Monday, 1 March 2010

Who benefits politically from a weak economy?


Figures showing the UK economy grew by 0.3% in the final quarter of 2009, rather than by 0.1% as previously estimated, are little help to either of the two main political parties in making the case for their economic policies ahead of the election.

Labour will be relieved that the economy has emerged from recession but reluctant to make too much of the stronger growth. In particular, they will be aware that growth in the first quarter of 2010 could disappoint due to the bad weather we have been experiencing and the likelihood that the increase in the main rate of VAT from 15 to 17.5% in January led to some spending being brought forward into the final months of 2009. And the first estimate of Q1 GDP will be published on 23rd April – probably right in the middle of the election campaign. Labour are also keen to emphasise that the fragility of the economic recovery makes it unwise to cut government borrowing by more than set out in last year’s Pre-Budget Report.

The Conservatives have stressed that they would take the health of the economy into account when deciding the scale of any spending cuts and tax increases to be included in the budget measures they hope to introduce within 50 days of winning a general election. But, as George Osborne made clear again in his Mais Lecture on 24 February, they would take steps to bring government borrowing down faster in 2010/11 than set out in the current Government’s plans. Whatever the economic rationale behind such a move, for this to seem like a sensible course of action the economy needs to be growing at something more than a snail’s pace.

So, while very low – or even zero – growth in the first quarter of 2010 would be bad news for Labour, it will be hard for the Conservatives to capitalise because it also throws into question one of their key economic policies. Perhaps the Liberal democrats would be the beneficiaries – not regarded as responsible for the recession and not advocates of early cuts in government borrowing.

Tony Dolphin, senior economist, ippr