Showing posts with label ash cloud. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ash cloud. Show all posts

Friday, 23 April 2010

What election?

Stranded in a hotel room half way around the world in east Beijing, you would probably forgive me for being a little out of the loop when it comes to the latest General Election developments. Sure, I can log on to the Guardian and track Andrew Sparrow’s live blog or get the latest election headlines on CNN in between rolling footage of ash cloud and stranded tourists, but in the English language press here in China there’s very little coverage of the closest electoral contest in 20 years in Britain.

That said, one article in yesterday’s Global Times, China’s leading daily for international affairs did catch my eye. Indeed, it is the one and only piece I have seen on the UK election since arriving in Beijing last Tuesday. The paper ran the story about Nick Clegg calling for the end to the ‘special relationship’ between Britain and the US:

‘The leader of one of Britain’s most important political parties said on Tuesday that the ‘special relationship’ between Britain and the United States was a relic of a bygone age and needed reassessing.’

The article then goes on to say that this latest interjection by Clegg comes at the end of a ‘remarkable week’ in which he has become, referring to round one of the televised TV debates, ‘an overnight sensation’ with support for the Liberal Democrats moving up ‘in some polls to parity with the ruling Labor (sic) party’.

According to the reporter, ‘Clegg’s party could win the election, and in the event of a hung parliament... he could play a key role in forming a governing coalition.’

Couched alongside successive articles (here, here and here) dismissing the call from some US senators for China to revalue the Yuan, and another in the state-run China Daily reporting a recent US poll that suggests that 80 per cent of Americans have no faith in the federal Government, this latest article about a relatively minor incident in the British election debate appears to conform to a particular trend.

While I don’t doubt that there is genuine interest in European politics in China, this article has as its raison d’ĂȘtre one thing and one thing only. This coverage of Nick Clegg, the ‘star so far of the campaign’ according to the newspaper, has nothing to do with the Liberal Democrats’ prediction of the financial crisis or the party’s policies for public service reform in Northern England.

Instead, it has everything to do with the message that this particular story conveys to the Chinese people: China is not alone in its critique of the US, China is right to stand up to the US and China should continue to do just that.

This minor piece of coverage of the British electoral debate in China serves merely to reinforce Chinese perceptions of the US during the latest cooling of relations between the two global superpowers. One thing is for sure, while a future Prime Minister Clegg might expect a somewhat guarded welcome on his first state visit to DC, he would likely be greeted much more warmly in Beijing.

David Nash

Tuesday, 20 April 2010

Every ash cloud has a silver lining

Most of those stranded on foreign shores – including my colleague David Nash, whose keynote presentation at a symposium in Beijing seemed like a good idea at the time – will fail to appreciate the ash cloud’s silver lining.

It’s equally hard to see how British businesses will benefit or how those whose products rely on fast delivery to market, such as the flower growers in Kenya, will appreciate the bright side of the continuing ban on flights to and from the UK.

According to Independent newspaper – using Reuters copy – though, there are ten silver linings to the cloud of volcanic ash currently hovering over northern Europe. These include lower risk of stroke, which apparently is heightened by aircraft noise, and saving 1.3 million tonnes of carbon dioxide emissions; equivalent to the annual emissions of 50 of the world’s poorest countries.

Slightly different estimates of the carbon emissions saved are available here, but you get the picture.

So why is a climate change researcher such as me not rejoicing? Because aside from clearing the skies of west London (and allowing the people of Hounslow to return to their back gardens for what, by coincidence, was a scorcher of a weekend), the ash cloud’s temporary excoriation of all aircraft and their vapour trails from our skies brings mostly economic pain and major inconvenience. And from an environmental perspective, there has been no structural change. Once the ash cloud has gone, it will be business as usual; the emissions saved utterly trivial.

What, on the other hand, the continued eruption of the world’s most unpronounceable volcano shows with great clarity is that whether we like it or not, our economy and the way we live our lives is heavily reliant on aviation. Ground planes – for whatever reason – and at least some of the machinery of globalisation grinds to a halt.

Is there an electoral silver lining? Certainly the conjuring of Dunkirk spirit is never a bad thing (it worked for Thatcher in 1983), although there is a danger that politicians merely look impotent at the hand of nature and, as such, it’s equally hard to see how the non-incumbents can make political capital out of the ashes.

If anything, the volcanic ash has exposed – once again – how vulnerable the current model of globalisation is and how trying to deal with emissions from aviation, whose growth will be a major problem for future governments, simply by curbing flying is a political non-starter.

When the ash cloud lifts and planes take to the air again, we need politicians to think about how we can accelerate technological innovation to reduce emissions from aircraft permanently, how the noise, misery and health impacts that jet aircraft bring to those grounded under their flight paths is reduced, how to replace flying where possible with hi-tech alternatives and how gradually we can shift to a more sustainable model of global trade.

Andrew Pendleton